Posted in focus on faith

What happens when you believe in Santa-God?

9957573-santa-claus-with-a-bag-of-money-stock-photoThere’s something I call “Santa-God theology”: if we are good little girls and boys, Santa-God will reward us with everything on our want-list. But the painful realities of life in the real world don’t support this belief.

The wilderness school for the soul teaches that God will not always protect us from suffering and disappointment. No–in fact, God may wish that we experience suffering and pain so that we come to know Him fully.

When Santa-God doesn’t come through we ask ourselves:

  • I feel like I’m doing all the right things — I teach, I sing, I give, I bring a pie to everything — why don’t I ever sense His presence?
  • Was my conversion real? Or was I riding an emotional wave?
  • If God is in control of my life, why do bad things happen to me?
  • Where is this joy the preacher keeps talking about?
  • Other than an abundance of disappointments, what’s so “abundant” about my life?

Many believers ask themselves these questions. For the Christian who is experiencing spiritual drift, this type of thinking begins to take a foothold, opening the door to doubt that can shove its way in and start to take over. (excerpt From Faking it to Finding Grace)

Many believers who find themselves in a season of dryness cannot pinpoint a date or time or reason for the beginning of their drift away from God, but most of them can relate to the problem of Santa-God theology. North American evangelical culture (it’s music and message) often supports this idea that God can be persuaded by our good behaviour to make all our dreams come true.

That’s Disney, not Truth.

Why don’t the people espousing Santa-God theology ever talk about the fact that every one of Jesus’ disciples, except John, died a violent death?

What happens when you believe in Santa-God? Life happens! Real life! Things go wrong. We lose–the game, the job, the relationship. We get hurt. We don’t get promoted. People die, even children. The poop of real life hits the fan of our illusion (Santa-God) and the resulting mess causes us to get scared, turn away, question God, and drift into the wilderness of doubt.

The journey out of wilderness is a journey into mature faith. Faith that is supported by Scripture; faith that works in the real world. In order to have a mature, workable faith, we must believe in the God of Scripture, not the God of our wishlist.

The real God is good. He loves you. So much, in fact, that He gave Himself in your place when He sent His Son to die on the cross as payment for your sin. (John 3:16) Sin?! What sin? The sin of thinking you don’t need God, that you can be our own god. (Game show buzzer sound!)

Maybe you believe in Santa-God but never realized it. Perhaps you are in a season of dryness and you don’t know how you got there or how to get out. If so, stick around as we explore spiritual dryness and mature faith in this series of blogs (go here and here for more). Join the conversation any time so we can travel together and help each other along the way.


Christian writer and speaker trying to follow God one yes at a time.

3 thoughts on “What happens when you believe in Santa-God?

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s